
Karma, Status, Solidarity, and Dominance in Sentiment Networks






| Outgoing tie | Target status | Sender's status |
|---|---|---|
| Positive (+) | High | Gain (+) |
| Negative (−) | Low | Gain (+) |
| Positive (+) | Low | Loss (−) |
| Negative (−) | High | Loss (−) |




| Actor A | Actor B | Position match | Predicted sentiment |
|---|---|---|---|
| High status | High status | Similar | Solidarity (+) |
| Low status | Low status | Similar | Solidarity (+) |
| High status | Low status | Different | Hostility (−) |


One tie per pair (antisymmetric, complete) — but arranged as a cycle, which a pure dominance order cannot contain.



| Triad | Structure | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Null (003) | No ties | No competition yet |
| Single edge (012) | A → B | The starting point for iterative competition |
| Double-dominant (021D) | A → B, A → C | Signature of winner effects |
| Double-loser (021U) | A → C, B → C | Signature of loser effects |
| Pass-along (021C) | A → B → C, no A–C tie | Transitivity not yet resolved |
| Transitive (030T) | A → B, B → C, A → C | The expected triad under a linear order |
| Cycle (030C) | A → B, B → C, C → A | The violation — no clear hierarchy |


| Theory | Micro-mechanism | Local pattern | Global structure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Karma | Match what you send with what you receive | Virtuous / vicious loops | Positive / negative regions |
| Status | Align with others' sentiments (prestige) | Deference / dominance | Centralized hierarchies |
| Solidarity | Align with actors in the same position | Horizontal mutual ties | Cohesive horizontal classes |
| Dominance | Win, and let others watch | Transitive triads | Linear dominance order |
